Neither could I. I ended up redecorating my car with a caramel macchiato the other day because I had to lift it up from the top as my missus had hers in the other holder, causing the lid to pop off, and my hand caught the floating shelf to guarantee I splashed it everywhere. Very impractical placement of the cup holders with that shelf being right above! I'll keep trawling AliExpress and take a look at some universal one's and hopefully cop lucky.