LenEV2016

Distinguished Member
Joined
Sep 21, 2024
Messages
2,122
Reaction score
4,422
Points
1,184
Location (town/city + country)
Scotland
Driving
Not an MG
Not sure if anyone has seen this, Omoda 5 in Asia, driving along and rear axle collapsed.
The close ups don't give a lot of faith in the quality of parts/ workmanship.

1000029582.webp
1000029583.webp
1000029584.webp
 
That's poor welding, be it either manual or robotic, around 50% has not penetrated into the parent metal creating a crack, and that has rusted . The portion that has joined properly has then had to take the stresses and forces which should be shared across the whole welds and fractured due to it not being large enough and consequently now being over stressed for its cross sectional area.
 
That's poor welding, be it either manual or robotic, around 50% has not penetrated into the parent metal creating a crack, and that has rusted . The portion that has joined properly has then had to take the stresses and forces which should be shared across the whole welds and fractured due to it not being large enough and consequently now being over stressed for its cross sectional area.
Yeah it's really poor
 
Very poor weld inspection, both robots and hand welders get their welds inspected. That wasn't welded professionally on either side, the weld on the side that had the tiny bit of contact at the lower corner, was a rather poor stick weld attempt ..... that should have been pick up on the predelivery inspection, even if it was completely missed at the factory ......
My guess is someone tried to fix it without removing it from the vehicle and they could only get partial access from one side. They deliberately avoided excess heat where the rubber bush was, so, even though the weld might have looked ok, it only penetrated one piece of the joint, and barely at that ..... you can see on the poorly welded side, the black paint sprayed in through the gap during assembly

T1 Terry
 
Looks like an easy fix to me.🧐
Agree, punch the bush out and weld it on properly. You can see the tack weld intended to hold it in place ready for the robot or welder to finish the job .... it just never happened.
The worry is, if this weld was missed, how many others ..... and no idea what the idea was with the crap weld that was added later ....

T1 Terry
 
Perhaps Stuart could monetarise this forum by allowing the motor manufacturers to question the members about problems they have with their new and existing models. The depth and range of experience and knowledge contained here should be worth a pretty penny ?:D
From diagnosis of problems such as this and to alternative fixes of how to get it through an MOT test ( Salty ) , why waste an excellent pool of talent. ;)
 
Support us by becoming a Premium Member

Latest MG EVs video

MG4 EV Refresh + NEW MG4 EV Urban - UK arrival dates, prices, specs (2026)
Subscribe to our YouTube channel
Back
Top Bottom