total loss of power on a busy dual carriage way - I'm really scared it will happen again

Similar happened to me last August (MG5 Trophy) on motorway with family on board. The car was serviced by Virtu MG Edinburgh West who recovered the car and drove us home without charge (good!), but it took 8 months to get fixed (2 failed battery cells). Virtu didn't have a technician to MG's required grade to assess the issue - a technician had to take a course, then scope of repair was not agreed between MG and Virtu, then Virtu did not have the tools and needed to hire from MG who had rented them out elsewhere - all in all, took 8 months. Hire car was eventually approved but was never provided and compensation was refused by MG. I went to court. MG have agreed to pay my claim in full.
Oh goodness. I was kind of of expecting to be back on a set of wheels this week, even be it a hire car. Following your post (and unsatisfactory engagement with the customer service team at the dealership - to quote them "it doesn't take seconds") it looks like I need to be prepared for a long & bumpy ride. Thanks for your post.
 
So after 3 weeks of diagnostics MG have determined that the drive motor needs replacing. I very much hope this is a reliable fix 🤞
 
I can't recall anyone needing a new drive motor , so that's rare in itself. A new one , by all accounts should be good and reliable and you are indeed unlucky to have suffered that. But , 3 weeks for diagnosis is absolutely ridiculous , either the MG technicians know their product or don't and have to keep referring the matter " upstairs " or have no say in the financial outcome of their investigations again passing the problem to higher authorities who then can decide on the most suitable ( cheaper ) solution. I bet a majority of that 3 weeks was toing and froing of 24 hr( or more ) delayed responses from MG UK to SAIC and back , whilst yourself the car and the mechanics sat there waiting. Unfortunately not an isolated incident and of course the major reason why many will not choose MG again . Doubly unfortunate that many other manufacturers are following suit in a race to the bottom if other forums are to be believed. :mad:
 
I can't recall anyone needing a new drive motor , so that's rare in itself. A new one , by all accounts should be good and reliable and you are indeed unlucky to have suffered that. But , 3 weeks for diagnosis is absolutely ridiculous , either the MG technicians know their product or don't and have to keep referring the matter " upstairs " or have no say in the financial outcome of their investigations again passing the problem to higher authorities who then can decide on the most suitable ( cheaper ) solution. I bet a majority of that 3 weeks was toing and froing of 24 hr( or more ) delayed responses from MG UK to SAIC and back , whilst yourself the car and the mechanics sat there waiting. Unfortunately not an isolated incident and of course the major reason why many will not choose MG again . Doubly unfortunate that many other manufacturers are following suit in a race to the bottom if other forums are to be believed. :mad:
Thanks for your interest. It seems to me that every stage of diagnostics had to be referred to "MG" (be that SAIC or MG UK, I'm not sure). Despite sketchy updates I believe the garage have been waiting on feedback/instruction on at least 3 occasions before actually getting to the point of identifying the problem being the drive motor. & Yes each wait is at least 24 hours long, in fact ordinarily 48 hrs. It is a weird system! Certainly I've not experienced this with any of my previous cars (all ICE). It's probably a complete coincidence that the first time I've come across this system is with an electric car. Anyway, I've been lucky to have got a courtesy car (initially they said it would be a 3 to 4 week wait but it was 1 week). & ulimately I just don't want that kind a breakdown again
 
Mechanics have had about a century of experience with ICE motors. With proper training systems in place for the latest tech.
EVs are very new in comparison and much fewer of them around. But I would have thought there could have been a few highly qualified techs in each country.
Maybe SAIC want to keep their secrets to themselves?
 
Mechanics have had about a century of experience with ICE motors. With proper training systems in place for the latest tech.
EVs are very new in comparison and much fewer of them around. But I would have thought there could have been a few highly qualified techs in each country.
Maybe SAIC want to keep their secrets to themselves?
Might also be a cultural thing, perhaps in China it’s frowned upon to make decisions at a certain level without referring everything to the higher ups?
 
Having gone through the warranty repair process it wasn't until I emailed MG and accused them of taking up to 48 hours to get back to the dealer and micro-managing the process that they approved the replacement of the Integrated Charging Socket.
 

Are you enjoying your MG4?

  • Yes

    Votes: 1,012 77.9%
  • I'm in the middle

    Votes: 191 14.7%
  • No

    Votes: 96 7.4%
Support us by becoming a Premium Member

Latest MG EVs video

First Look: MG IM5 & IM6 – Premium EV Saloon & SUV Unveiled at Goodwood!
Subscribe to our YouTube channel
Back
Top Bottom