MG4 vs ID3

[siteguru]

I'm perfectly happy to agree to disagree ... as I know for a fact that I am 100% correct.

 

[Ian Key]

Model year 24 with wipers and bigger wheels not MY23.

Nope ... MY22 was the first phase; the second phase of the MG4 (rear wiper, 3rd rear head rest, OPD, bigger wheels on the Trophy) came out in 2023 so was Model Year 23. There have been no MG4 updates so far in 2024 hence no MY24 cars.

It's possible that @Deleted member 2148 and @siteguru are both right in that the car was manufactured in 2024 but it's the 2023 specification.

 

[Deleted member 2148]

I'm perfectly happy to agree to disagree ... as I know for a fact that I am 100% correct.

Not according to MG who describe the current model as MY24. Humility can be a gift.

 

[mg4mc]

Reference?

It's probably confusion over Model Year (which is what MY normally means) and the manufactured year which is just when it was made. Many dealers take the manufactured year and (incorrectly imo) abbreviate it to MY just to confuse everyone.

 

[siteguru]

Not according to MG who describe the current model as MY24. Humility can be a gift.

As I (and others) have said ... there have only been two specifications* (to date) during the life of the MG4 - the original 2022 specification, and the 2023 update. Any cars supplied or built during 2024 are still to the 2023 specification, hence Model Year 23 (MY23) as opposed to Manufactured Year.

* I don't mean SE vs Trophy etc.

 

[Deleted member 2148]

As I (and others) have said ... there have only been two specifications* (to date) during the life of the MG4 - the original 2022 specification, and the 2023 update. Any cars supplied or built during 2024 are still to the 2023 specification, hence Model Year 23 (MY23) as opposed to Manufactured Year.

* I don't mean SE vs Trophy etc.

All car manufacturers release updates mid to late year. On ice cars it’s October and despite being 2023 are designated MY2024. The update due late summer/autumn this year will be MY2025 cars as has always been the case.

 

[kiwi]

I have the same experience as @Deleted member 2148, my December 2023 MG4 is documented as MY2024.

 

[tsedge]

All these things can be true at the same time:

• Manufacturers have a new model year every year, so they like to talk about MY2024 MG4s, MY2025 etc...
• Sometimes these are minor changes to car parts and improvements to how they are made in the factory, so they not user noticeable.
• Sometimes these are bigger changes such as the Phase 2 cars that came with OPD, rear wiper, 3rd headrest, which are user noticeable.

Note that manufacturers often make smaller manufacturing changes continuously and don't wait for MY change overs to optimise their factories.

 

[Rolfe]

I just registered my car with MyEnergi, as I got a Zappi. The only option for the MG4 is MY22.

 

[staarek]

Coming back to the original post, I decided on ID3 (77kWh) rather than MG4, and so far (early days) I'm very happy (I'm coming from MG5). The promised mileage seems to be true, the car is very efficient up to 65-70mph, pleasure to drive, easy to charge and very comfortable. Here's a photo from the trip from the dealer - it's all motorway, but it was busy with roadworks & rush hour hence low average speed.

 

[pecker]

Coming back to the original post, I decided on ID3 (77kwh) rather than MG4, and so far (early days) I'm very happy (I'm coming from MG5). The promised mileage seems to be true, the car is very efficient up to 65-70mph, pleasure to drive, easy to charge and very comfortable. Here's a photo from the trip from the dealer - it's all motorway, but it was busy with roadworks & rush hour hence low average speed.

I loved mine, until I didn't, I just had too many problems that they all seem to suffer from around the 3 year mark.

Hope your ID.3 turns out to be more reliable than mine was.

 

[staarek]

I loved mine, until I didn't, I just had too many problems that they all seem to suffer from around the 3 year mark.

Hope your ID.3 turns out to be more reliable than mine was.

Thanks, this one is exactly 3 years old, what kind of issues did you get?