Moving On From MG4

securespark

Prominent Member
Joined
Sep 26, 2023
Messages
1,487
Reaction score
1,928
Points
583
Location (town/city + country)
Stockport
Driving
MG4 (2022-2025)
As we are now into the last year of our lease, I am looking at what to get next.

It has to be easier to get into and out of, have a much bigger boot and preferably, a little extra width in the back to carry 3 more comfortably.

Mrs Secure is not so anti EV as she was, as long as she can get at least 300 miles in the next car (bearing in mind the lowest we get in the MG4 is 200) and we can charge quicker than our usual 50 minutes or so from 10-90.

But I'm still running a list of potential hybrids, just in case.

The current shortlist of EVs are:

Skoda Enyaq 82: big on space.
Nissan Ariya 87
Ioniq 5 84: picked because the onboard charging gubbins can charge more quickly?


The list of hybrids are:

Kia Sportage PHEV
MG HS Hybrid +
Renault Austral

Any and all comments welcome!

Thank you.
 
My only comment is that after owning an EV, although only a short time for me, I wouldn't want to switch back to a hybrid (which I had before the EV), I love that all my charging is done at home, and I really wouldn't want to have to start using smelly petrol pumps again.

And that's my 2 cents thrown in. 😊
 
Would the MG S5 not make it onto your shortlist as it's only just sub 300 miles. With a bigger battery pack it would be on my shortlist, I'd have to forgive MG for deleting the electronically dipping rear view mirror for a standard manual dipping version across the range at present. They might listen to customer feedback and include it like they did for the rear wiper on the later MG4's
Is the Skoda Elroq not on your list too? Skoda at present however does not support V2L function on the Elroq, I'm not sure if the Enyaq does either if that is important to you.
The other consideration is the endless options list and price creep when you start to spec up some of the other EV's. I like MG's approach of SE and Trophy.
 
*udi e-tron Q4 , sorry just cannot say it. If the new price is prohibitive there are some really nice low mileage examples at dammed good prices. Although you could bet the dealers would screw you down on the 4s residuals.
 
Whilst price will be a factor, I think @securespark is planning another lease rather than a purchase. So it'll be lease deals that matter rather than outright car price.
I thought it was possible to lease nearly new cars depending on the dealership or leasing company. Its not an area I know much about .
 
Would the MG S5 not make it onto your shortlist as it's only just sub 300 miles. With a bigger battery pack it would be on my shortlist.
Yeah, can't remember what size battery it has.

But it's the MRSSR that counts here, not the manufacturers figures.

MRSSR = Mrs S range.... The official range of out LR MG4 is 270-odd, but we can rely on a minimum of 200 Mrs S miles!
Is the Skoda Elroq not on your list too? Skoda at present however does not support V2L function on the Elroq, I'm not sure if the Enyaq does either if that is important to you.
Never used it, TBF....

Not sure the Elroq measures up in the rear cabin bumroom department. I think the Enyaq squeaks a bit more.

The other consideration is the endless options list and price creep when you start to spec up some of the other EV's. I like MG's approach of SE and Trophy.

Sure. We will take a hit on things like the cams and the phone services and other stuff.
 
Yeah, can't remember what size battery it has.

But it's the MRSSR that counts here, not the manufacturers figures.

MRSSR = Mrs S range.... The official range of out LR MG4 is 270-odd, but we can rely on a minimum of 200 Mrs S miles!

Never used it, TBF....

Not sure the Elroq measures up in the rear cabin bumroom department. I think the Enyaq squeaks a bit more.



Sure. We will take a hit on things like the cams and the phone services and other stuff.

The S5 quoted is 290mls, I figured 250 measuring on 160 miles over mostly motorway and dual carriageway. My local mileage is far better. Spacewise it's excellent but try it for yourself.

EV3 was my 2nd favourite choice, it's a bit lower but might still be ok for you. Bit of an issue with the 'safety' settings though as in you can't turn them all off...

The Enyaq has many varients, make sure you go for a higher spec as the low spec doesn't have heated seats, steering wheel or ACC (has cruise, just non adaptable)..

My next work car is going from an MG5 to I'm told an Arriya, if you can wait a month I'll let you know what I think of it ;D
 
Everest, EV3!

It is now on our shortlist.

5teep, the current base model Enyaq, the SE-L has heated seats and wheel and ACC.

We went to see and drive both yesterday.

EV3 may physically not be as tall as Enyaq, but the passenger seats can be adjusted to the same heights off the road.

Unfortunately, despite the Skoda dealer knowing we were interested in SE-L, the demonstrator was a Sportline, which didn't have the 19" wheels the SE-L is shod with. On top of this, it had lowered and stiffened suspension. It had 235/50 R20's on the front and wider 255/45 R20's on the rear.

The net result was that it performed similarly to the MG4 in terms of dealing with potholes, speed bumps and sleeping policemen. Just not quite as bad.

The boot is the big selling point of Enyaq. 585 litres, vs 460 for the EV3 vs 363 for the MG4.

The EV3 also has a 25 litre frunk, which the charging cable can be stored in.
We bought one for the MG4 and have only used it a handful of times (and I think we will get one with the car if we choose an EV3) but it will be easier to lift the bonnet to get at it if needed than getting it out with a full boot.

One of the things I wanted to measure was the interior width between the door cards front and rear.

Now, the MG4 and EV3 are very similarly sized cars.

Enyaq is around 4" wider than EV3, externally, including the mirrors.

But my internal dimensions tell a different story.

My measurements between the door cards just above the arm rests in each car are as follows:

MG4 Front 149.5 Rear 145
Enyaq Front 150 Rear 146
EV3 Front 151 Rear 148

We also sat in the back of Enyaq and EV3 and measured the available space left in the middle, the Enyaq had just 2cm more than the EV3.

There are lights in the rear of both, the EV3 has a touch sensitive button in the overhead panel which you can tap to turn them on if elderly parents are struggling to get their seatbelts on. Tick!
Also a tick for the other camp, Enyaq has a door unlock button in the middle, rather than on the driver's door like the EV3 and MG4. It's daft, I know, it just makes me feel a bit better that I can reach it!

The small screenwash reservoir size of the MG4 has increasingly peed me off. It's amazing how it's tiny, seemingly inconsequential things like that that really niggle!

So I got nerdy and looked up the sizes for these two cars.

Apparently Enyaq is 5.5 litres (which makes sense, as my 2002 Octavia was the same, or just slightly less) and EV3's is 3.78l. And according to the specs, there are warning indicators on both cars for low washer fluid too.
So, either way, it's a big improvement.

We drove the EV3 in a different area. One of the things we wanted to test was driving the car over a really badly made road, as one next to our road is full of bumps and potholes and is a pain every day.

Luckily, there was one near the dealer that was even worse! And the Kia coped very well.

The GT Line model we drove had 19" wheels, compared to the base Air's 17". The car had EV-specific Hankook tyres.

It had a much more compliant ride than the Enyaq, but then, it's probably not so much of a driver's car like the Sportline, less so the MG4.

It also handled potholes and speed bumps much better. My spine didn't complain once!

But I can't imagine chucking the FWD EV3 round the country lanes like the RWD MG4.

I'm no longer a driver, but I think I'll miss that!

Our conclusion is that we would like to try and drive an SE-L Enyaq to see how much difference the non-lowered, non-stiffened suspension with the same size tyres as the Kia we drove makes to the ride quality.

It's just a question of whether any dealers have one as a demonstrator.

The Enyaq being around 4" wider must make it a bit more of a pain to park in car park bays. But the extra boot space is really attractive.

I'd like to think it would fare better in a prang, but do you consider crash safety when you choose a motor?

I mean they are mostly 5 star these days, but some have better side, front and rear impact scores. And, having driven commercial vehicles up to 7.5t, you do feel safer higher up.

Edited for clarity.
 
Last edited:
Thanks! Is that a polite way of saying I'm a nerd?
🤣
No, I'm the first to say I'm nerdy!

But seriously, the Enyaq is a great car, but if the SE-L doesn't ride like the EV3, then that's a biggie, because ride comfort is one of the things we are looking to change.

The big boot is a draw, but then the car is significantly wider, which could be a drag (literally) in car parks.

The other thing I forgot to mention is that the interior is brighter and lighter in the Kia, but that's because there's a lot less black. The downside is, it'll need more frequent cleaning!

Of course, if none of the dealers have an SE-L to drive, we'll have to make a decision based on the Sportline.
Or hire one for a day, but that seems a bit extreme!
 
Last edited:
Support us by becoming a Premium Member

Latest MG EVs video

MG4 EV Refresh + NEW MG4 EV Urban - UK arrival dates, prices, specs (2026)
Subscribe to our YouTube channel
Back
Top Bottom