What do you value most in your EV?

If the ZS EV and the MG5 had the same range, technology and price, which one would you buy?


  • Total voters
    42
  • Poll closed .
I see Toyota, having missed the BEV car boat, have brought out a BEV van now. Still no cars though (apart from the overpriced Lexus brand)
 
I asked this question on the most recent Podcast, but I thought I'd open it up here for more general discussion.

If the ZS EV and the MG5 had the same range (say 250 miles), and if they both had the same technology (MG Pilot, roof loads, panoramic roof etc), and if they both cost exactly the same, which one would you choose?

I'm wondering if the Crossover or Estate format is what swings it for you, or whether it was due to the availability of features on the MG ZS that swung it one way, or the extra range of the MG5 which swung it the other way.

Thanks in advance!
I would always opt for the SUV / Crossover type car as it is much easier to get in and out if you have back issues Like me. I also have a Seat Leon and over the past couple of weeks I Once again had issues with sciatica due to having a compressed disc in my back. With a bit of difficulty I could get into the ZS where as the Leon was a complete no go area, I simply could not get down that low to get into it.
 
Looks like there's definitely room for an Estate and a Crossover within the MG brand - they don't necessarily poach sales off each other.

Will be interesting to see if anyone switches teams once the upgraded battery versions are launched in the near future?
Hi @MilesperkWh .
What is your best "Guess" at a release date for the larger battery model in the ZS ???.
Are you thinking 64 kw or even a little larger ?.
A real world range of 250 miles be fantastic.
 
Seems to be telling me the ZS EV is for geriatrics :LOL:
This fact maybe true, but we have to bare in mind that there are still younger people who have mobility issues, that can limit their choice of certain models types.
The crossover / SUV has now taken over from the family hatchback recently.
Even a couple with a young family, can see the benefits of loading small children and their prams etc into a car with a higher ground clearance.
There is NO joy lifting a two year old child into the back seat of a car and trying to fasten the child seat restraint while suffering from a bad back !.
A two door car is WHOLE new world of pain.
 
This fact maybe true, but we have to bare in mind that there are still younger people who have mobility issues, that can limit their choice of certain models types.
The crossover / SUV has now taken over from the family hatchback recently.
Even a couple with a young family, can see the benefits of loading small children and their prams etc into a car with a higher ground clearance.
There is NO joy lifting a two year old child into the back seat of a car and trying to fasten the child seat restraint while suffering from a bad back !.
A two door car is WHOLE new world of pain.
Well said..!!
 
Will be interesting to see if anyone switches teams once the upgraded battery versions are launched in the near future?
I'm guessing that will all depend on the premium to upgrade. If new prices start matching the opposition e.g. eNiro, at least for the ZS that will muddy the waters. The 5 currently doesn't have any direct competition so a little less confusion there.
For the same price would people unfamiliar with the brand choose MG over Kia or Hyundai, Skoda, Nissan etc ?
Or is the MG going to maintain it's price sector ?
 
Hi @MilesperkWh .
What is your best "Guess" at a release date for the larger battery model in the ZS ???.
Are you thinking 64 kw or even a little larger ?.
A real world range of 250 miles be fantastic.
Best guess for ZS facelift would be Q4 2021. Expect a choice of 2 battery sizes, as per Niro, albeit with increased capacities. I'm led to believe it will be 50/70kWh. 😳
 
Best guess for ZS facelift would be Q4 2021. Expect a choice of 2 battery sizes, as per Niro, albeit with increased capacities. I'm led to believe it will be 50/70kWh. 😳
Will there be other improvements Miles other than just battery size?
 
Could be 73kWh.
NewZS.jpg
 
The body changes will probably follow the ICE face lift and I believe the dash dials will be digital.
 
I would imagine there will be a number of design changes both inside and outside to update the model. We will have to wait and see!
Will Chorley Group be leading the way with attractive part exchange packages for those with MG ZS that wish to upgrade; thus helping the MG ZS EV 2nd hand car market for those struggling to purchase new EV Vehicles?
 
Will Chorley Group be leading the way with attractive part exchange packages for those with MG ZS that wish to upgrade; thus helping the MG ZS EV 2nd hand car market for those struggling to purchase new EV Vehicles?
We'll obviously be doing the best we can in offering competitive deals, as per usual.
 
a 300 mile ZS or 5 would be phenomenal if it is still affordable.

Obviously will be more expensive, but how much more is the big question ?

How much do you think would be tempting or how much to put it out of budget ?
 
I have an MG5 Excite and love it - I had the opportunity to drive around in a ZS for a few weeks and would admit that it was comfy to drive but I have found that it is much easier to get high efficiency driving out of the MG5 (about 4.5+ in this warm weather - smaller cross-section through the air?). The MG5 Excite interferes less with your driving when on cruise control and uses regen when the ZS doesn't. If the ZS was brought up to MG5 specs on the drive-train and visa versa for the cabin comforts, it would make deciding between them more difficult. The MG5 also seems to be less conspicuous as an EV - I would still chose the MG5, but the vote would be soo close.
 
a 300 mile ZS or 5 would be phenomenal if it is still affordable.

Obviously will be more expensive, but how much more is the big question ?

How much do you think would be tempting or how much to put it out of budget ?
That is the major question- with an increased range the price will go up.
 
a 300 mile ZS or 5 would be phenomenal if it is still affordable.

Obviously will be more expensive, but how much more is the big question ?

How much do you think would be tempting or how much to put it out of budget ?
I'd pay £30-35k for a ZS with a 73kWh battery, as long as there were some good dealer or MG offers.
 
Support us by becoming a Premium Member

Latest MG EVs video

MG3 Hybrid+ & Cyberster Configurator News + hot topics from the MG EVs forums
Subscribe to our YouTube channel
Back
Top Bottom