I moved to Sheila's Wheels some years ago because they came up top on one of these comparison sites then, and they've been absolutely fine. However, I didn't see a single quote from them on the returns this time.
Money Saving Expert came out more than the Compare The Market best quote.
However, I have business to conduct with Aviva today, and went to the site to do that. I saw their car insurance right next to the investment bond I need to do something about, and went on to that, prompted by what
@tsedge said above.
It looks very competitive, although it depends on what extras I want to add to their £404 basic price. Better than my existing policy anyway.
Hmm. I lost the original quote by accident while trying to remove the foreign driving cover, as I think I probably won't go abroad this year. I think the renewed quote was about £10 more due to the few days delay. Not the end of the world.
I've been able to include protected no claims discount in that, which apparently I didn't have with my last policy. I didn't realise that, I certainly wanted it as I have 20 years worth. Fortunately however the accident that totalled Prospero was fully acknowledged to be the other guy's fault, so I've still got it.
Since my starting offer was £702.72 from my previous insurer, I call this a win.